JWR Articles: Film/DVD - For Your Consideration 2014 - Best Picture (Directors: Wes Anderson, Alejandro González Iñárritu, Anton Corbijn, Tate Taylor) - December 31, 2014

For Your Consideration 2014 - Best Picture

5 5

A quartet of hopefuls

Ah, ‘tis the season of film awards of all stripes. What follows is a series of capsule reviews and a prediction two. Winners, will then be given the full-review treatment.

Colourful cast and sets

The Grand Budapest Hotel
Wes Anderson
100 min. Five stars

Wes Anderson has outdone himself, proving to be the reigning Mother of Invention in this magical production that looks (superb cinematography from Robert Yeoman; Adam Stockhausen’s production design is a marvel of colour, texture and details), sounds (yet another wide-ranging score—most notably the delectable choral elements—from Alexandre Desplat) and acts (the all-star cast will delight everyone: Tony Revolori as Lobby Boy Zero proves to be every bit as secure as his far more experienced colleagues) at a consistently high level. Filmmaking seldom comes together simultaneously on so many planes. JWR

Production photo

Alejandro Iñárritu
119 min. Two stars

How extraordinarily disappointing. After such a masterful job with the multithreaded Babel (cross-reference below), Iñárritu serves up a truly fanciful production that is long on characterization but woefully short in the realities of the theatre: for as much as critics love to think they have the power to make or break art, it is the public—especially in this social media age—that decides what wins and what doesn’t. (Look no further than Phantom of the Opera running in virtual perpetuity across the street from the venue that houses the play within the film.) Michael Keaton is the ideal choice as the film superhero, desperate for respect “on the boards” (er, hello there Joan Rivers, cross-reference below). His nemesis comes in two forms: seat-filling co-actor, Mike (Edward Norton who sears through his opening scenes before being relegated to the sidelines) and crotchety critic (Lindsay Duncan) whose vow to kill the show sight unseen very nearly eliminates its star instead. Still the phrase “cutting off your nose to spite your face” takes on new meaning here. JWR

A Most Wanted Man
Anton Corbijn
122 min. Two and one-half stars

John le Carré’s spy novels are amongst the most difficult in the world to successfully bring to the screen (large or small). His unerring sense of moment and brooding, psychological development are huge challenges: two productions have managed to succeed: miniseries Smiley’s People (1982 with Alex Guinness) set the standard that most others never achieved until Gary Oldman found the magical tenor and tone in Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (2011 cross-reference below).
Alas, Corbijin’s examination (along with screenwriter Andrew Bovell) into “Why the world will never be a safe place” never gets comfortable in its skin (despite Philip Seymour Hoffman dutifully swigging scotch and puffing cigs—or perhaps because of it?). Such a great pity given the talent involved—on and off the screen. JWR

Production photo

Get on Up
Tate Taylor
138 min. Three and one-half stars

Despite some fine performances (notably Chadwick Boseman as the ever-energetic James Brown and Dan Aykroyd as manager and confidante Ben Bart), the writing trust (Jez and John-Henry Butterworth along with Steven Baigelman) can’t find a consistent groove to keep the narrative in sync with the music.

That said, the production numbers steal the show—as they should with such an incredibly varied and engaging body of work from which to choose—but the man-behind-the-“act” must await another treatment. Given the long career, this life seems more the stuff of a mini-series than a big-screen extravaganza. Any takers? JWR

Prediction: Take The Grand Hotel Budapest from this lot.

Your comments are always welcome at JWR.

Click here to have your say (please mention the headline for the article):Feedback to JWR.

Further information, future screening/performance/exhibition dates,
purchase information, production sponsors:
Cross-reference(s): Please click on the image link(s) below
for related work: