JWR bannerReviews banner
JWR design component

 

gone with the woman

(Tatt av kvinnen)

Norwegian flag (2007)
92 minutes

Back to Film, DVD & Video Reviews

Reviewed at the 2008 Palm Springs International Film Festival
by S. James Wegg
(01/09/08)

2 and a half stars

Him and Marianne
Him and Marianne

Dive comedy flounders in the shallow end

There’s so much to admire in the Norwegian contender for Oscar’s foreign-language run off:  beautiful Norse scenery deftly captured by Marius Johansen-Hansen; clever special effects (digital team headed by Fredrik Höglin; especially lovable is the airborne Valentine heart—complete with an arrow of consummation—can’t fail to bring a smile); a colourful score (original music by Aslak Hartberg) ranging from a perfectly balanced Christmas chorus to steel guitar and banjo tracks that’s sure to be the envy of stateside Country & Western fans); some fine acting (Trond Fausa Aurvåg’s “Him” is dolefully wimpish and hilariously macho as required and his swim/diving sequences are first rate; Marian Saastad Ottesen as the bossy, spontaneous and faithless Marianne makes the most of an uneven character) and a Greek Chorus of advisors for the lovelorn who sport nothing but towels, jowls and saggy flesh in the après swim sauna).

Unfortunately, the script (Petter Næss and Johan Bogaeus drew the screenplay from Erlend Loe’s novel) has less intuition than Him is accused of lacking, wandering from scene to scene with little undercurrent of purposeful, if discreet, direction.  The outrageous moments work best (Marianne’s explosive dad is a hoot) but production never finds the necessary balance of fine madness/plausible actions.  The retired Swedish colonel (Sten Ljunggren) gets the line-du-jour “Once you understand life, you can’t use it anymore.”  Modified to fit Naess’ result it might well read “Once you don’t understand credibility—especially in humour—you can’t amuse anymore.” JWR

Director

Petter Næss

Writers

Petter Næss, Johan Bogaeus (screenplay) Erlend Loe (novel)

Producer

Olav Øen

Original Music

Aslak Hartberg

Cinematography

Marius Johansen-Hansen

Film Editor

Inge-Lise Lanfeldt

Main cast

Trond Fausa Aurvåg, Marian Saastad Ottesen, Sten Ljunggren, Henrik Mestad, Anna Gutto, Thérèsa Brunnander

 

right gif

905.938.9755 - jamesweggreview@bellnet.ca  - Copyright © 2001-2008 James Wegg & Associates/JWR
The content of this page is the sole responsibility of JWR and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of its advertisers and sponsors.