JWR bannerReviews banner
JWR design component

McKinley string quartets

Back to CD and Radio Broadcast Reviews

by S. James Wegg
(03/28/07)

starstarstarstar


Three welcome soundscapes

This trio of string quartets by Elliott Miles McKinley provides a varied feast of textures, ideas and emotions that delight the ear and warm the soul.  His soundscape approach, relying more on combinations than solo lines with accompaniment is not unknown in the literature, but the magical mixture of vibrant jazz, traditional forms and copious amounts of unison (OK, two cups of dissonance to balance all) combine memorably and in an instantly accessible fashion.  McKinley String Quartets - CD cover

The oh-so-Western hues of No. 4 with its long liquid lines (if only the vibratos always matched) and energetically into the string punch (and near-perfect ensemble from The Martinů Quartet) evoke not just Copland and Ives, but the equally skillful string craft of Hershey Kay (Stan Getz  reference).  Then the Presto Vivace, intriguingly glued together with an upper-range pedal, compelling forceful if a bit tight, sets the stage for the contrasting, oddly whimsical, deliciously titled Morbidamente con Movemento, whose gooey final utterance slides into and lingers in memory for days.

The Finale’s “Pizz ‘R Us”—a saucy combination of fun and angst is superbly balanced by recording engineer Radek Rejšek—winds down with a lazy walk away from the rhythmic and harmonic fray, punctuated at every turn before yielding to consonance.  The Stamic Quartet (and in particular cellist Vladimír Leixner’s solo interventions) deliver No. 3’s dichotomy of dankly brooding and nervously childlike lines, colours and contrasts with considerable skill and understanding.  The fiendishly difficult monophonic language from viola and cello is appropriately dark and emotive but unanimity in the changes must wait for another occasion.  Yet the through-composed architecture is built with strength, ease and understanding as required and, after a mini-catalogue of themes and motif past, conveys McKinley’s slight sliver of hope in the last adieu perfectly.  The fifth quartet is a compositional quilt of styles and moods that begs a push on the replay button.  Amongst its features are a Rite of Spring opening where pizz replaces the bass drum, a Ragtime that’s a tad quick for Joplin’s fabled “ragged time,” a brutal Tango that searches and swings, an intensely expressive Chorale, a drunken swagger and a “tidy up” coda that reviews, revise and reflects before slipping away into the night.  Reminiscent of Hindemith’s ability to write in any style, McKinley’s art is as varied as the planet and happily repays repeated visits. JWR

String Quartet No. 4
1. Arioso
2. Presto Vivace
3. Morbidamente Con Movemento
4. Allegro Con Brio

String Quartet No. 3
5. Largo e Maestoso
6. Allegro Ma Non Troppo
7. Grazioso
8. Lento con Tristezza

String Quartet No. 5 (Part 1)
9. Introduction
10. Ragtime
11. Slower, With A Half-Time Feel
12. With Lightness
13. Ritornello
14. Tango

String Quartet No. 5 (Part 2)
15. Still, With Great Breadth
16. Chorale

String Quartet No. 5 (Part 3)
17. With A Touch Of Swagger
18. Interruptions
19. Ritornello II
20. Coda

Elliot Miles McKinley String Quartets performed by:
The Martinu String Quartet and The Stamic Quartet

Recording time: 63' 58"

This CD is available through www.mmcrecordings.com

right gif

905.938.9755 - jamesweggreview@bellnet.ca  - Copyright © 2001-2007 James Wegg & Associates/JWR
The content of this page is the sole responsibility of JWR and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of its advertisers and sponsors.