JWR Articles: Live Event - Gurre-Lieder (Conductor: David Zinman) - September 15, 2010 id="543337086">


3.5 3.5

When just getting there isn’t an option

Expectations were very high for an evening of art, enlightenment and passion (full disclosure: after all of these years sitting in the dark listening to concerts around the world, this was the first live performance of Schönberg’s Gurre-Lieder yet heard).

Sadly, it took just a few measures to realize that conductor David Zinman had bitten off more than he could musically chew.

With his head largely buried in the complex score, the music-making barely scratched the surface of one of the most magnificent scores to touch down on planet Earth.

Too many ensemble and balance problems gave the impression more of a dress rehearsal than a polished performance. In fairness, with so many forces involved, rehearsal time was likely at a premium, but the music doesn’t care about the economic realities of twenty-first century concert production. In any event, the goal of reaching the finish line still standing wasn’t enough to justify the enormous effort from so many individuals.

The visual metaphor of the men’s/mixed chorus being unable to rise or sit as one (all it takes is a single gesture from the podium) foreshadowed the soon-to-be-heard consonant cacophony and unintelligible (except when lightly accompanied) text.

Thank goodness for the soloists.

Christine Brewer was a compelling Tove, searing through her ill-fated role with a surety of pitch and varied dynamic range that made every phrase memorable.

Despite a tendency to push much of the time (less is always more, but that would also require commensurate cooperation from the podium), Stephen Gould delivered a full-blooded Waldemar infused with conviction and drama (“Herr, du solltest wohl erröten— “Lord, you should be ashamed”—spoke volumes).

As Waldtaube, Petra Lang tore into the music and wouldn’t let go—much to the obvious delight of the crowd and the best personification of Schönberg’s cast: a more impassioned “Wood Dove” is hard to imagine.

Stephen Powell was resplendent in the brief but essential mood-changing part as the Peasant (unfortunately introduced by somewhat “untogether” strings).

Andreas Conrad (the Jester) used his flexible voice and wide-ranging visage to great effect, but couldn’t buy a chuckle from the surprisingly dour patrons.

Playing the Speaker, Wolfgang Schöne was superb in his Sprechstimme, notably “Hu! wie’s schaurig (“Ho! Eerie sounds waft over”) and “um Leben und Sonnenschein” (“to make a lively dance in the sunshine”).

Here’s to a future remount with the same, dedicated forces but with one important change of leadership to bring a much more cohesive result. JWR

Between Performances

During the festival’s 38-day run, a wide variety of non-musical activities was sampled both in Lucerne and other parts of Switzerland. Because of the excellent local and inter-city transportation system, there’s plenty to see and do within a day’s reach and still be back in time for the next performance—Cultural Tourism at its best!

Zentrum Paul Klee, the art museum in Berne is strong on special exhibits (Klee Meets Picasso) and offers a very comprehensive children’s program. Just a quick train and then bus ride from Lucerne, there’s lots of time to take in this wonderful array of art. JWR

Your comments are always welcome at JWR.

Click here to have your say (please mention the headline for the article):Feedback to JWR.

Further information, future screening/performance/exhibition dates,
purchase information, production sponsors:
Cross-reference(s): Please click on the image link(s) below
for related work: